Pages

Friday, 20 November 2026

Excellent Women by Barbara Pym: “I’m afraid there is nothing at all dramatic about them”

“I wondered that she should waste so much energy fighting over a little matter like wearing hats in chapel, but then I told myself that, after all, life was like that for most of us—the small unpleasantnesses rather than the great tragedies; the little useless longings rather than the great renunciations and dramatic love affairs of history or fiction.” (ch.11) 

That is the art of Barbara Pym: she writes about small, mundane things, and specialises in ordinary, mediocre people, to whom not much happens. 

On a sentence level, I doubt anyone reads her for the similes:  

“The room was enormous, like something in a nightmare, one could hardly see from one end of it to the other, and as far as the eye could see was dotted with tables which were all full. In addition, a file of people moved in through a door at one end and formed a long line, fenced off from the main part of the room by a brass rail.” (ch.9) 

When I tried Jane and Prudence, I stopped reading after about 50 pages—why should we care about all these trivial thoughts of these trivial people? But now when I read Excellent Women, a better and more interesting book, I think I’ve understood her art and her appeal. 

“I felt that I did not like Mrs Napier any more than I had at our first meeting, and she was dropping ash all over my newly brushed carpet.

‘Will your husband be coming back soon?’ I asked, to break the rather awkward silence that had developed.

‘Oh, soon enough,’ she said casually. She stubbed out her cigarette in a little dish that wasn’t meant to be an ashtray and began walking about the room.” (ch.3) 

These seemingly insignificant details reveal a lot about both Helena Napier and Mildred Lathbury (the narrator). 

Compared to Jane and Prudence, Excellent Women has a more interesting story: Mildred Lathbury is an ordinary, church-going single woman in her 30s, one of those excellent women that others take for granted; she has been having a quiet, uneventful life when the Napiers move into the same house, who are facing a marital crisis and dragging her into their messy lives. Rockingham (or Rocky) Napier is a charming man who was in the Navy (and “spent his time being charming to dull Wren officers”) and his wife Helena is an anthropologist, who is now in love with another anthropologist called Everard Bone. Their worlds are not Mildred’s. Look at the scene in which Mildred listen to Helena and Everard Bone reading their paper before the Learned Society:  

“It was a pity I had not thought of reading up the subject a little; that would have been far more to the point than buying a new hat. It was humiliating to realise that everybody in the room but me understood and was able to take an intelligent interest in what Helena was saying. I fixed my eyes on her with a fresh determination to concentrate, but then my attention was distracted by the old lady with her knitting.” (ch.10) 

Mildred Lathbury is not an intellectual woman—she is ordinary and unremarkable—her preoccupations are small and even trivial. And yet Barbara Pym somehow gets us to care about Mildred, about her small concerns and useless longings, about her feeling that “their lives so full and yet so well organised, that I felt more than usually spinsterish and useless” (ch.3). Mildred can sometimes get a bit tiresome, in her self-pity and small-mindedness, but there are some poignant moments—at times you feel sorry for her and at times you see yourself in her. 


The quote in the headline comes from ch.8. 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Be not afraid, gentle readers! Pick a name and share your thoughts!
(Make sure to save your text before hitting publish, in case your comment gets buried in the attic, never to be seen again).