Pages

Friday, 14 June 2019

The Double Life of Veronique: doubles and choices

I have always found it difficult to write about The Double Life of Veronique

The film is about 2 young women—Weronika in Poland and Veronique in France. They look alike (both played by Irene Jacob), though Weronika is more animated and passionate, and Veronique is more melancholy, with her head in the clouds. They have many things in common: both grow up with a single father; both sing and have beautiful voices; both have a heart condition; both rub their eyelids with a gold ring, and so on.  
They are not aware of each other till 1 day, Weronika happens to see Veronique on a trip. Soon after, Weronika dies. 
Reviews and essays usually say the basic premise of the film is that the 2 women are not aware of each other’s existence, but somehow Veronique “learns” from Weronika’s mistakes, like she is given a 2nd chance. Weronika prioritises singing above everything else, including her heart, and it kills her; Veronique gives up singing lessons.  
That’s not the way I see it. To me, The Double Life of Veronique, above all, is about a feeling—the feeling that maybe there is someone in the world who is just like me, like a lost twin, a double. Have you ever had that feeling? I have, which is why I have a bit of an obsession with doubles. It could be a warm thought—maybe I’m not alone. But at the same time it’s also discomforting—maybe I’m not unique, maybe I don’t really matter. 
At the same time, it should also be seen in the context of Kieslowski’s work. Kieslowski’s interested in chance, and the different paths one may take. In Blind Chance, 3 scenarios lead to 3 different lives and career paths. It could be that all 3 are the different possibilities. It could also be that the 3rd one is real, as the film begins with Witek screaming, and he thinks about the other lives he might have had if he had got involved in politics—perhaps that could have saved him. 
Later in Three Colours: Red, Kieslowski again tackles the theme of chance and different paths: a retired judge meets Valentine (also played by Irene Jacob), after years of disillusionment and cynicism, and wonders what may have happened if they had met 40 years earlier; but his life finds parallels in a young law student, and at the end of the film, the student meets Valentine. 

In The Double Life of Veronique, Kieslowski uses doubles and the idea of parallel existences (Weronika and Veronique) in order to play with the same theme—the 2 women are like the same person in different scenarios because of their different choices. 
See what Roger Ebert says: 
“Kieslowski almost never made a film about characters who lacked choices. Indeed, his films were usually about their choices, how they arrived at them, and the close connections they made or missed.
Most films make the unspoken assumption that their characters are defined by and limited to their plots. But lives are not about stories.
Stories are about lives. That is the difference between films for children and films for adults. Kieslowski celebrates intersecting timelines and lifelines, choices made and unmade. All his films ask why, since God gave us free will, movie directors go to such trouble to take it away.” 
Read the entire review. 
“Because he made most of his early work in Poland during the Cold War, and because his masterpiece "The Decalogue" consists of 10 one-hour films that do not fit easily on the multiplex conveyor belt, he has still not received the kind of recognition given those he deserves to be named with, like Bergman, Ozu, Fellini, Keaton and Bunuel. He is one of the filmmakers I would turn to for consolation if I learned I was dying, or to laugh with on finding I would live after all.” 
I’ve read Kieslowski on Kieslowski (edited by Danusia Stok) recently, and at the moment I’m reading The Cinema of Krzysztof Kieslowski: Variations on Destiny and Chance by Marek Haltof. These books remind me of how much I love Kieslowski.

8 comments:

  1. i mull re time... does it really flow like a river? does it exist only in human minds? what is it like on other worlds? does it split like a fork in a river, creating multiple realities? etc.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Interesting.
      Have you seen any Kieslowski film?

      Delete
  2. Coincidently, I've read another review published yesterday on a French blog (https://newstrum.wordpress.com/2020/03/01/la-double-vie-de-veronique-de-krzysztof-kieslowski-conte-et-parabole-inachevee/) about this film.
    In addition to what you said in this post, the blogger insists on how, maybe, Weronika unknowingly "saved" Véronique, giving her the opportunity not to repeat her mistakes, and how the film is therefore simultaneously optimistic and sad.
    On the cinematographic level, he also points out how the green color is used in a manner similar to "Vertigo".
    Both your reviews has given me a tremendous want to revisit this movie, which I feel I haven't properly watched a long time ago and haven't revisited since, though in the meantime, I've watched and loved Kieslowski's trilogy.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't understand French, the auto-translation option doesn't work very well. How is the colour green used in a manner similar to Vertigo?
      I think you've probably seen Amelie. When I watched Veronique the 1st time, I saw the influence.
      And yeah, the trilogy is more well-known but I just love this film more, probably because of my obsession with doubles. The idea of saving is interesting. I suppose it works.

      Delete
    2. Very roughly, the green color is, as in "Vertigo", a symbol of death. In numerous scenes, according to him, the frame is increasingly invaded by this color, reflecting how Weronika is also nearing her own death. It is a constant color throughout the film and reminds all characters of their permanent proximity to death. It is in this beautiful passage of his :

      "Le vert de la mort contamine cependant toujours les couleurs du film qui se poursuit à Clermont-Ferrand, ainsi cette lueur verte qui nimbe étrangement les têtes des enfants regardant un spectacle scolaire, permanence du vert mortuaire qui forme comme le fond du tableau ; car la mort, on ne pourra jamais la chasser complètement : il faut juste ne pas en avoir peur."

      Have to admit I've never seen "Amélie". I've always had a prejudice toward this movie, reinforced by bad reviews (don't remember which ones) I've read about it. Do you like this movie?

      Delete
    3. Did you agree when you watched the film again last night?
      I liked Amelie, but the thing about it is that it's one of the few non-English language films that are extremely popular among people who never watch non-English language films. So some of the fans are quite annoying. I don't think it's among the best films ever made like people say.
      I did like it though.
      If you watch it, you can see the influence of Veronique in terms of style and plot.

      Delete
    4. I agree with what he said, and I also notice that art is associated with death : the green color is extensively used when Weronika sings and dies, when Véronique watches the marionettist's show, and when she reads his books.
      My dislike of "Amélie" comes from what I think is a cliché vision of France. And the fact that so many people like it also gives me a prejudice towards it : it's true that foreigners tend to quote this movie as an example of French cinema, ignoring at the same time masters like Renoir, Bresson or Tati...

      Delete
    5. I find it interesting that you're ignoring the French New Wave.
      And yeah, as I said, it's very popular among people who don't really watch non-English language films, including French films.

      Delete

Be not afraid, gentle readers! Comment! Discuss! Argue!
(Make sure to save your text before hitting publish, in case your comment is swallowed by the whale and disappears forever).